Chapter 5: Insurance-Related Crimes
Arson: A Costly Crime
 
US arson facts
  • Arson-the act of deliberately setting fire to property for fraudulent or malicious purposes-is a crime in all states.
  • Arsonists destroyed $1.5 billion in insured property, including buildings and motor vehicles, in 1998.
  • Vandalism is the leading cause of arson.
  • Between 20-25% of arson fires are drug-related.
  • Children are responsible for almost half of the arson fires set in the US.
  • Arson crimes are hard to solve-the FBI estimates that only 16% of 1998 arson cases ended in arrests.
  • Motives for arson usually include direct and indirect financial gain, revenge, concealment of another crime, fun or to relieve boredom, or emotionally related causes.
US arson statistics

According to an Insurance Research Council study, only about 14% of arson suspects are said to be motivated by a desire to defraud an insurer.

The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) estimates:

  • There were 76,000 deliberately set or suspicious structural fires in 1998-the lowest level in the last 11 years-down 3.2% from 78,500 in 1997.
  • The 1998 estimated property loss figure of $1.2 billion was 4.6% lower than the $1.3 billion in 1997.
  • There were 470 civilian deaths due to arson-an increase of 5.6% from the 445 in 1997
Ohio arson statistics
According to reports from the Ohio Fire Marshal's Office, 4,393 incendiary fires-including structures and vehicles-occurred in 1998, a decrease of 12% from the 1997 figure of 4,993. An additional 4,273 "suspicious" fires were reported in 1998, as compared to 4,344 the previous year. State reports also showed 101 civilian injuries, 10 deaths and nearly $41 million in losses resulted from Ohio arson activity in 1998.
Ohio's anti-arson program

The Ohio Blue Ribbon Arson Committee-composed of fire fighters, police officers and insurance officials-offers rewards for information leading to the identification of the person(s) responsible for an act of arson. The fund was established in 1978, with reward money provided by the insurance industry.

Through December, 1999, 302 rewards totaling more than $275,000 have been awarded to recipients since the program's inception, many of whom request anonymity. Its efforts assisted in the successful resolution of at least 308 cases set by arsonists, 85 of which were attempts to defraud insurers. The savings to the Ohio insurance industry are in excess of $3.7 million.

The program works by placing posters at the sites of suspicious fires. Individuals with information concerning the cause of the fire call local police or fire officials, whose telephone number is listed on the poster. Awards from the fund are made by the Blue Ribbon Arson Committee.

Recent breakthroughs

State laws now allow for insurers and law enforcement agencies to exchange arson information, which eliminates the threat of civil suits for libel or violation of privacy.

Thanks to technological advancements, sophisticated modeling programs help arson investigators understand how and where fires originate. This enables investigators to better determine fire patterns that can provide clues as to whether the fire was intentionally set.

Wildfire losses for the last decade show an annual loss of 2.5 million acres caused by an average of 58,128 fires.
(National Interagency Fire Center)
1997-1998 Ohio City Arson Report
CITY 1997 1998 CITY 1997 1998 CITY 1997 1998
Ashland 4 0 Kettering 17 24 Sharonville 0 2
Athens 0 2 Lakewood 8 12 Sheffield Lake 2 NA
Bainbridge Township 3 0 Lebanon 1 3 Shelby 1 NA
Barberton 15 21 Lemon Township NA 1 Solon 14 10
Beavercreek 27 16 Liberty Township 1 0 Springdale 0 1
Bedford 2 0 Lima 15 11 Springfield 43 27
Berea 5 7 Lorain 30 26 Springfield Twp.(Ham. Cty.) 7 8
Bexley 1 1 Loveland 3 NA Stow 14 9
Bowling Green 2 0 Madison Twp.(Lake County) 4 5 Streetsboro 5 1
Brecksville 1 0 Mansfield 35 40 Strongsville NA 6
Bucyrus 2 5 Marietta 7 5 Sylvania 1 NA
Cambridge 0 1 Marion 13 17 Sylvania Township 0 3
Canton 69 61 Mason 1 0 Tallmadge 10 22
Centerville 3 5 Mentor 9 8 Tiffin 4 1
Chillicothe 21 16 Miamisburg 8 10 Toledo 395 347
Cincinnati 677 NA Middletown 21 23 Trotwood 29 34
Clearcreek Township NA 4 Newark 10 NA Troy 8 2
Cleveland 631 467 New Philadelphia 0 1 Twinsburg 1 6
Columbus 778 813 North Canton NA 5 Union Twp.(Butler County) 16 13
Cuyahoga Falls NA 29 North Ridgeville 1 0 Upper Arlington 8 10
Dayton 210 NA Norton 1 3 Vandalia 4 4
Delaware 11 7 Norwalk 3 3 Van Wert 8 5
Delhi Township 3 3 Norwood 4 16 Vermilion 2 2
Dover 2 0 Oregon 4 5 Wadsworth 9 6
Englewood 7 5 Oxford NA 6 Warrensville Heights 3 3
Euclid 8 5 Parma Heights 15 0 West Carrollton 12 7
Fairborn 4 6 Perkins Township NA 1 Westerville 17 29
Fairfield 18 10 Perrysburg 1 0 Westlake 6 3
Fremont 9 3 Perry Twp.(Stark County) 8 2 Whitehall 35 14
Gahanna 13 14 Pierce Township NA 1 Wickliffe 2 0
Goshen Township 7 6 Portsmouth 6 3 Wilmington 1 5
Grove City 1 1 Ravenna NA 3 Worthington 0 4
Hamilton 40 69 Reading 0 1 Xenia 3 10
Hilliard 13 1 Reynoldsburg 7 7 Youngstown 267 319
Huber Heights 14 8 Sandusky 4 9 Zanesville 25 17
Jackson Township 10 NA Seven Hills 0 2    
Kent 17 9 Shaker Heights 7 2      
Note: Statistics are shown for Ohio cities and towns 10,000 and over in population when an act of arson was reported during 1997 or 1998.
NA = Not available

Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reports, 1997 & 1998
Fireworks-related injuries were down in 1998 compared to the previous year. The US Consumer Products Safety Commission estimates that 7,000 were treated for fireworks-related injuries in 1998, compared to 8,300 in 1997. About 1/3 of these injuries are associated with illegal or homemade fireworks.
(National Council on Fireworks Safety)